How Ravishankar Prasad can resolve the 700 MHz spectrum auction pricing problem

broadbandIndia is getting ready for a digital revolution by auctioning 700 MHz spectrum that has the potential to take high-speed Internet to every village in the country. However, telecom operators — who have to play the role of the enablers — are not popping open the bubbly quite yet.

The reason for their misgivings is the high financial commitment that they have to make to get their hands on 700 MHz spectrum.

A LITTLE BACKGROUND

Cellular spectrum can be divided into two types — high priced, high propagation and low priced, low propagation.

As the name implies, the first type covers a lot of distance, but costs more; while the second type comes cheap, but covers only a smaller area.

Why is this important? If more area can be covered by a single tower, that saves a lot of money for operators who can then sell their service at a lower cost.

For example, if you were to use the current, popular band of 2300 MHz to set up a 4G network, you will need around 6 lakh towers to achieve pan-India coverage. And it’s not just the 6 lakh towers — you also need to connect these towers using a fiber network too.

If, on the other hand, you are using 700 MHz spectrum, you can achieve the same coverage using 1 lakh or fewer towers. In fact, CDMA operators have achieved near ubiquitous coverage on the adjoining 800 MHz spectrum with less than 50,000 towers nationally.

This reduction in the number of towers can save operators a lot of money. An average cell site costs around Rs 30,000 per month, or Rs 3.6 lakhs per year. Over the 20-year lifespan of the auctioned airwaves, the total cost per tower works out to Rs 72 lakhs.

So, if an operator chooses 700 MHz spectrum instead of 2300 MHz, he can save at least Rs 72 lakh multiplied by 5 lakh, which works out to Rs 36,00,00,00,00,000 or Rs 3.6 lakh crore.

In addition, this also saves the operator from having to build lakhs of km of fiber backbone to connect these high-speed towers, which would be another substantial amount. In total, therefore, the switch to 700 MHz would save them Rs 5 lakh cr or more during the validity period of the airwaves.

Now, let’s compare this savings with the price of the spectrum. The TRAI has suggested a base price of Rs 1.15 lakh cr for a decent 10 MHz block, compared to a price of around Rs 8,200 cr for the low-propagation 2300 MHz band.

In other words, to make the switch from 2300 MHz to 700 MHz and save Rs 5 lakh cr in tower and fiber costs, operators have to pay an extra Rs 1.07 lakh cr over the next 13 years in terms of spectrum charges.

The choice, you’d think, is not that difficult to make. After all, if you can save Rs 5 lakh cr over the next 20 years by paying Rs 1 lakh cr in the next 13 years, why wouldn’t you?

TOO LONG A PERIOD?

The problem is that no one really knows what is going to happen to wireless telecom in the next 20 years. In fact, it’s difficult to predict what will happen in the next 8 years.

This makes telecom companies wary of committing such a huge amount of money.

Even Mukesh Ambani’s Reliance Industries, which has invested Rs 1 lakh cr over the past 3 years in its telecom venture Reliance Jio, doesn’t have the stomach to shell out another Rs 1 lakh cr.

Reliance Jio, like Bharti Airtel and Idea Cellular, asked the government to postpone the sale of the 700 MHz spectrum.

The problem is not the price itself as much as the duration of the commitment.

For example, the savings of Rs 5 lakh cr over 20 years translates to a saving of Rs 25,000 cr per year, while the spectrum price of Rs 1.15 lakh cr for 20 years translates to just Rs 5,750 cr per year.

Looked at in this way, it makes total sense for the company to pay Rs 5,750 cr and save Rs 25,000 cr next year.

But the catch is that the government is seeking a commitment for 20 years when no one is able to predict with any certainty what the shape of the business will be in the longer term.

For all you know, new light-based or satellite-based technology could reduce the value of this spectrum to nothing after 10 years. Just like technology can reduce the spectrum value in the future, it could also increase it manifold, and Rs 1 lakh cr could look like peanuts after five years. No one really knows.

As a result, the operators are wary of shelling out the amounts and want the government to give the spectrum cheaper to them by reducing the reserve price. Of course, lower prices would also help increase any windfall gains they stand to make 10  years from now.

More justifiably, the operators justifiably point out that they are not in the business of speculation, but communication. By insisting on selling spectrum for 20 years, the government is forcing telecom companies a speculative play on the value of the spectrum in the future.

If both parties are adamant in their stands, there is a possibility that the operators could boycott the 700 MHz auction.

This would be a set back for India as a country, as there is nothing — except Reliance Jio’s 800 MHz service — that can replace this band in taking broadband to the villages.

THE SOLUTION

The ideal solution is reduce the risk for the operators, while protecting the interests of the public of the country by ensuring a fair valuation. This can be achieved by cutting the tenure of the spectrum award.

In other words, in addition to the price, let operators also bid for tenure. So, instead of putting in a bid for Rs 50,000 cr for 20 years, allow them to bid for Rs 5,000 cr for five years, which they are most likely to.

In fact, given the potential valuation upside to wireless spectrum in the next 8-12 years, it would also be unfair to the taxpayers to ‘sell’ this spectrum for 20 years and let the operators keep any upside to the valuation in the future.

If variable tenure sounds complicated, the government can also just cut the validity period of the airwaves in half — to 10 years.

This will not prevent operators from buying the airwaves or building new networks using this spectrum. Reliance Jio, Reliance Communications and Tata Teleservices are deploying 4G networks on spectrum that is valid only till 2022 — another six years.



Reliance Jio NOT TO EXTEND free data offer after March Reliance Jio will not be extending its Happy New Year free data offer beyond March 31, according to our sources in the company.The clarification comes in the wake dozens of reports claiming that it will extend the free scheme beyond the March 31 deadline into June."There is zero chance of that happening," said a senior official in the company's sale...
Idea Cellular – Vodafone merger announcement soon? Idea Spectrum HoldingIdea Cellular has put off the trimonthly meeting of its board of directors scheduled to take place tomorrow, raising speculation that it may soon announce a merger or deal with Vodafone India.The meeting was supposed to take on-board results  of the telecom operators' working the three months from October to December.After t...
Reliance Jio now allowing unlimited night downloads under Happy New Year plan Reliance Jio is now allowing its users to download an unlimited quantum of data at night under its Happy New Year offer.This is different from the earlier practice of allowing users to consume only 4GB of data per 24 hours.With this new feature, subscribers can download or consume 30 GB or 40 GB or even more data between 2 am and 5 am without aff...
How to overcome Reliance Jio’s 1GB limit by timing your downloads According to our tests, it is possible to download more than 1 GB using a single Reliance Jio connection using the Happy New Year offer.According to our tests, there is no limit on the number of GBs that can be downloaded under the Happy New Year offer between 2 AM and 5 AM.In our tests, we have been able to download over 40 GB in one night, without ...
Vodafone halves 4G data prices: 4 GB at 255 | 22 GB for 999 Vodafone has halved data prices, six months after cutting them by about 40%.Under the new 4G tariff announced today, customers will get 4 GB of data for Rs 250 and 22 GB for Rs 999.These are roughly half of the prevailing data rates in the market.The current data price in the market is 2 GB for Rs 250 and 10 GB for Rs 999.Vodafone is also off...
1GB LIMIT: Reliance Jio starts restoring full speed at end of day Reliance Jio, India's largest provider of wireless data, has modified its bandwidth limitation policy to restore full speed for the subscriber under its Happy New Year offer the next day.So far, a 4G subscriber who crossed the daily FUP limit of 4GB or 1GB had to wait for exactly 24 hours for Jio to lift the speed limits.Under the new policy, he ...
Airtel doubles 3G speed in Delhi with more spectrum Bharti Airtel, India's top telecom provider, introduced its second 3G carrier in Delhi, more than doubling the speed of the existing network for most smartphones.Not only has the company introduced a second 'carrier' (block of spectrum) adjacent to the first one, it has also implemented the technology to merge the two blocks into one, thus boosting downl...
BSNL to start 4G services only after April – CMD Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd, the state-owned telecom services provider, will start its 4G services only in the next financial year that starts in April."BSNL is likely to start 4G services in 2017-18," Anupam Shrivastava, the chairman and managing director of the company said.The company has fallen far behind all its rivals in putting up 4G networks e...
BSNL to soon relaunch Rs 498 “truly unlimited” 3G plan, new packs on Republic Day State-owned Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd has decided to "relaunch" its 14-day "truly unlimited" 3G plan, chairman and managing director Anupam Shrivastava said today.The plan, introduced in early December, was pulled after only one month. It offered truly unlimited 3G data usage at just Rs 498 with a validity of 14 days.The 498 recharge was one of th...
Idea Cellular increases free data in unlimited scheme by 4 times Idea Cellular today increased the free data allocation on its existing unlimited calling packs.Compared to 1 GB of 4G data that customers were getting with the Rs 348 pack, they will now get 4 GB.Similarly, the free data allocation for those who do not have 4G handsets has been increased from 50 MB to 3 GB per month -- an increase of 60 times. ...
Bharti Airtel to launch pan-India Payments Bank tomorrow Bharti Airtel, India's largest telecom company, will take a crucial step towards entering the financial services business as it launches its Payments Bank operation across India tomorrow.Payments Bank refers to a limited operations bank that can be primarily used for making transactions, and not for depositing money.The operator has already start...
SUPERHOUR: The SECRET behind Vodafone’s Rs 16 offer It is no secret that India's second biggest telecom operator by revenue -- Vodafone -- is under threat from a rapidly growing No 3 -- Idea Cellular -- and an aggressive newcomer -- Reliance Jio.Though Idea is still behind the British firm when it comes to total revenue, Idea has already overtaken Vodafone as far as the data business is concerned, acc...
Vodafone 4G reaches UP West; Goa, Chennai, Punjab next Vodafone has launched its 4G network in UP West and Uttarakhand offering "4 times" as much data for a 1GB pack.Among the first wave of cities are Dehradun, Haridwar, Aligarh, Nainital and nine other prominent business, tourism and educational hubs."4G services will soon be available across several other major towns across the circle by March 2017...
Bharti Airtel offers 3GB of 4G data free per month for one year, with conditions Bharti Airtel, which has come up with various 'free data' schemes of late, has kicked off one more such scheme -- offering 3 GB of free data per month for those availing certain handpicked recharge and billing schemes.For prepaid users, the free data is available if they recharge Rs 345 per month. The Rs 345 recharge also gives free unlimited voice calls...
BSNL offers email IDs in Hindi and other Indian languages BSNL has introduced a free e-mail service for its broadband users based on its डाटावन.भारत domain name.As a result, it is possible for a customer to now have an complete email address in Hindi.“It's now possible in every part of India to have an email address in their own language and communicate in preferred language”, said Anupam Shrivastav, Ma...