Left Front tries to tap anti-American sentiment with fat tax in Kerala

leftKerala finance minister Thomas Isaac defended the new tax imposed on Western food items in Kerala even as it became clear that move could be open to a challenge on the lines on which Maharashtra’s beef ban was overturned.

The communists of Kerala — not the biggest fans of American culture — imposed the ban on select fast food items in their first budget after coming to power earlier this year.

The items on which a punitive 14.5% tax has been levied are burgers, pizzas, doughnuts, sandwiches and pasta, even if these are being served in by a roadside vendor.

The ostensible reason for the tax is that these food items tend to make people fat and are therefore unhealthy and need to be discouraged. However, the claim falls short on several grounds.

First, the consumption of the above items in Kerala is negligible and confined to the cities. They perhaps account for less than 1% of the total fat found on Malayali bodies.

Other food items, including traditional fare such as ghee rice, biriyani, fried snacks and red meat — particularly beef — contribute much more to making Malayalis fat compared to tacos and burgers — which many in the state may not have tasted even once in their lives.

Not surprisingly, charges are being leveled that the Left front is trying to impose its anti-American cultural prejudice on the whole population.

The accusation is similar to the one that the Left successfully used against the BJP in the context of the ban on beef in Maharashtra. While the beef ban was seen as the imposition of Brahmanical culture on people’s food habits, the imposition of punitive taxes on only American snacks is being seen as the imposition of Left’s anti-Americanism on the Malayali palate.

The second interpretation is more cynical. Some believe that the fat tax is a cheap political stunt to tap into the rising anti-American sentiments among certain sections of the society. A large part of Kerala society increasingly sees the US as an aggressor trying to meddle in the affairs of other countries, especially in the Middle East.

Reacting to the controversy, Finance Minister Thomas Isaac clarified that the idea of a tax on the above Western food items was suggested by Muhammad Kabeer, who used to be a teacher at Center for Development Studies, Trivandrum. He also said the tax will collect no more than Rs 10 cr in a year, and said there were no other aims for it than to discourage unhealthy food items.

It remains to be seen if someone — most probably a multinational chain like McDonalds or KFC — goes to the court to challenge the ban on grounds of discrimination.

MINISTER DEFENDS

For now, comrade Isaac is busy convincing people the move does not stem from any antipathy towards the US — a country that the Left parties in India have spend decades feelings paranoid about.

“The intention behind the move is not to mobilize funds, but to draw attention to unhealthy food habits among Keralites,” he said in a Facebook post. “The controversy generated by the move indicates that we have succeeded in this endeavor.”

On the criticism that the move spares bigger culprits such as the maida parota — a staple in the state’s restaurants — Isaac said the government was open to expanding the ambit of the ‘fat tax’ going forward.

“It is not time to impose such a tax on food items consumed by ordinary folk,” he said. “Unlike in the west, such items (as sandwiches and burgers) are consumed by well off people in Kerala (who can afford to pay more),” he added.
[socialpoll id=”2373649″]



Siddhu on joining Congress: No party is good or bad! Navjot Singh Siddhu, the cricketer turned politician and a vehement critic of the Indian National Congress for several years, justified his decision to join the party saying that no party, by itself, is good or bad."No party is good or bad. The same party can be run by bad people, the same party can be run by good people," he said.He said he was will...
Katju says SP will defeat BJP in UP Elections; Demonetization, Akhilesh to aid Former Supreme Court judge and a keen observer of Indian politics, Markandey Katju has predicted a win for the Samajwadi Party led by Akhilesh Yadav in the upcoming Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections.BJP, which is seen as a strong contender by many, would be negatively impacted due to the impact of demonetization and the clean image projected by SP chief m...
Mayawati warns Muslims: Akhilesh vs Mulayalam will bring BJP to power Bahujan Samaj Party leader Kumari Mayawati has warned Muslim voters in Uttar Pradesh against continuing to vote for Samajwadi Party, claiming that the current fight between SP leader Mulayam Singh and his son Akhilesh would split their votes in two."I urge you not to let your vote get divided between Akhilesh and Mulayalam groups. If you do that, the...
Hindu fighting for Muslim rights alleges religious discrimination by orthodox Muslims Sreeja NeyyattinkaraSreeja Neyyattinkara, one of the state secretaries of Welfare Party in Kerala, has set off a storm among Dalit and Minority activist circles in Kerala by heavily criticizing some orthodox practices among the Muslims of the state.The criticism has come as a surprise as the Welfare Party is largely comprised of Muslim supporters an...
Rahul Gandhi’s gives ‘earthquake evidence’ on Modi After keeping the nation waiting for 10 days, Rahul Gandhi today dropped his 'bomb' on Narendra Modi that he had promised would 'cause an earthquake'.Gandhi said a company based in Uttar Pradesh has written "that Modi has taken money from them multiple times over six months."Quoting income tax investigation reports, Gandhi said: "They have writt...
Demonetization: Modi announces bumper prizes; 15 lakh users to get 1,000 rupees Narendra Modi announced several 'prize schemes' to promote cashless transactions.Under the schemes announced today, there will be two sets of prizes for consumers and another for small merchants.Under the first scheme, any customer who uses any electronic form of payment, including wallets and debit cards, will qualify for a 'lucky draw' of Rs 1,000 ...
Supreme Court bans liquor sales along national and state highways The Supreme Court of India has banned the sale of liquor along highways in India.It has ordered that all the licenses of liquor shops in and around the national and state highways in all the states should be closed when their licenses expire.During the trial, the court asked the central government for its opinion. The center said liquor shops on...
Subramanian Swamy attacks Ratan Tata for investing money in Britain Keeping up his attacks on Tata Group interim chairman Ratan Tata, BJP leader Subramanian Swamy fired yet another salvo at the veteran industrialist for investing huge amounts of money into Britain, instead of doing so in India.Tata Steel had acquired UK-based Corus for around 6.2 billion pounds in 2008, making the company the fifth largest steelmaker in ...
Domino’s Pizza starts cashless facility for phone orders Domino's Pizza has started cashless payment facility for those who order by phone as well."Post demonetization, we have seen many customers choosing to order online. Consumers coming to our restaurants to dine in or carry out are able to pay With Credit caras or Wassets. However, there are many customers who still order with a phone. It is for these cust...
Taxes will be made “more reasonable” in cashless India – Jaitley Taxes in India will be made more reasonable as more and more transactions switch to the cashless mode, finance minister Arun Jaitley said."As more and more transactions are made cashless, they will come under taxation.. (and with this) taxes will be made more reasonable, both direct and indirect," Jaitley said today.The finance minister was giving ou...
Allahabad High Court says Triple Talaq ‘unconstitutional’ The Allahabad High Court has today said 'triple talaq' or the divorcing of women under Islamic laws -- is unconstitutional in Indian law.The provision "violates women's rights" and no personal law board is above the Indian constitution, the court said while hearing a petition filed by a Muslim woman from Bulandshahr.The constitution of India assu...
Jayalalitha’s successor: Crucial meet starts at AIADMK headquarters The All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhakam (All India Anna Dravidian Progressive Party) started a crucial meeting of its top leadership at 6:30 PM today, minutes after the party hurriedly re-hoisted the flag on its headquarters.All the party's MLA's are attending the meeting.The decision to lower its flag at around 5:30 pm today had led to spec...
Sorrow after Tamil channels say Jayalalitha dead, AIADMK lowers flag The AIADMK has lowered its flag at its headquarters, setting off a frenzy of sorry in Tamil Nadu as desperate followers of Chief Minister J Jayalalitha broke down in tears.UPDATE: The AIADMK has rehoisted its flag after bringing it down initially.There were wailings and sobbings around the Apollo Hospital in Chennai, where Jayalalitha is being tr...
BJP asks all MPs, MLAs to submit bank statement to party As part of the ongoing crackdown on tax evasion and illicit funds, the Bharatiya Janata Party has asked all its MPs and MLAs to submit the full details of their banking transactions from Nov 8 onwards.The central leadership of the party will examine the bank statements of these representatives to check for any illegal or suspicious cash transactions....
7 ILLOGICAL REASONS to oppose DEMONETIZATION The current demonetization move by the Narendra Modi government has seen a lot of accusations and counter-accusations being levelled by both the supporters and opponents of the move.While the government has tried to deal head on with the official accusations levelled by opposition political parties, a much more subtle misinformation campaign is going o...