Kerala’s Nirbhaya case forces rethink on reliance on Bangladeshi migrants

jisha-rape-murder
The victim

The latest horror story to come out of Kerala has forced residents in this largely peaceful state to rethink their reliance on migrants — mostly from Bangladesh — for carrying out labour-intensive projects.

Over the last five days, gruesome details have emerged about how a law student was raped, tortured and killed in the afternoon right inside her home.

UNPRECEDENTED VIOLENCE

The body of the girl, Jisha, was found on April 28. Her injuries totalled 38, including some very deep bites that penetrated the flesh considerably. Both her shoulders were broken. A rod was used to penetrate her reproductive organ with such force that her intestines were spilled out, drawing parallel’s to the disturbingly similar Nirbhaya rape case that happened in Delhi.

Though Kerala’s attitude towards women is more conservative than all the surrounding states and most of India, the state has never witnessed a rape and murder case with such brutal aspects.

The gory and unprecedented details of the crime have created outrage among the population.

OUTSIDER INVOLVEMENT SUSPECTED

The brutal nature of the crime, and it’s location in Perumbavoor — an area known for housing a large number of Bangladeshi and other out-of-state laborers, has led to suspicions about the involvement of migrant laborers in the act.

Over the last 5 years, the south-Indian state has started to rely more and more on laborers from outside the state. Though about 70% of these labourers claim to be ‘Bengalis’, most of them claim to be coming from Assam.

Perumbavoor is on the rural hinterlands of Ernakulam, Kerala’s biggest city. With most Malayalis moving on to white collar jobs or doing blue-collar jobs in the Middle East, the state’s industries — especially construction and hotels — have had to import their labor in recent years.

People come from Assam, Nepal, Bihar, Eastern Uttar Pradesh, West Bengal and Orissa to work in Kerala, where a manual labourer is paid Rs 850 per day.

Perumbavoor, due to its location, served as a preferred residential location for many of these laborers.

NO FEMALES

However, these laborers are forced to live in ‘labor camps’ and single rooms with very basic amenities and shared toilets. In a state known for its cleanliness, the labour camps provide a visible contrast with its stagnant pools of dirty water and swarming mosquitoes.

Another big problem faced by the labourers is access to safe sex. Forced to live in camps with shared rooms, many have to go without sex for weeks and months, leading to psychological and social problems.

On the other hand, Kerala has the highest level of female literacy in India, and women routinely travel alone and do not think twice about walking alone on a deserted road. This leads to a kind of ‘clash of cultures’ as many of the labourers come from cultures where women are secluded and do not enjoy the kind of freedom that Malayali women are used to. In some ways, the problems are similar to that faced by women in Germany and other European countries after large-scale migration of a predominantly male population from the Middle East.

RISING CRIME RATES

According to the New Indian Express, the Kerala Police have registered 323 incidents of crimes involving migrant labourers in the last five years.

In the Ernakulam Rural police station limits — of which Perumbavoor forms a part — there have been 38 murders in the last five years. Out of these, at least 32 are directly or indirectly linked to migrant labourers, the New Indian Express said.

JISHA’S CASE

Jisha lived in a modest house with an easy-to-break-down door. The house was constructed earlier this year by labourers, some of whom were from outside the state.

The police found that the labourers continued to make calls to Jisha’s mobile phone in February, well after the construction was completed.

The police have arrested two migrant laborers including one who claims to be from Murshidabad (on India’s border with Bangladesh) — as well as others locals — in its hunt for clues. However, it is yet to make any substantial breakthrough in the case.

The police have come under criticism for trying to cover up the case.

No information about the incident was given to the media or to various statutory bodies that have to be informed if murders and atrocities are committed against Dalits, who enjoy special protection under the constitution as they have historically been targeted by other groups for exploitation and discrimination.

News about the case leaked after a policeman involved in the case described the horrendous details to his family, which included a girl who was studying in the same law college where Jisha was also pursuing her degree in law.

The girl then informed her college-mates who informed the media around five days after the incident took place. They also successfully mobilized public opinion using social media.

The Congress-led government has been accused to trying to brush the incident under the carpet so that it will not affect the mood of the electorate. The state will go to the polls to select a new government in less than three weeks.



Is Bangalore safe for women? Ask me, I’m a Bengaluru hudugi It's amusing to see men from Bangalore share posts on Facebook about how Bangalore is a safe city. And that, what happened on New years' was just alcohol-induced.Firstly, dear men of Bangalore, hold that thought. Would you care to ask a woman how she feels, before you post another status on Facebook?I’m a Bangalorean, I was born here, and lived h...
Allahabad High Court says Triple Talaq ‘unconstitutional’ The Allahabad High Court has today said 'triple talaq' or the divorcing of women under Islamic laws -- is unconstitutional in Indian law.The provision "violates women's rights" and no personal law board is above the Indian constitution, the court said while hearing a petition filed by a Muslim woman from Bulandshahr.The constitution of India assu...
Kerala merchant’s union strike against black-money currency move Kerala's merchants and traders union has asked its members to shut all shops from Tuesday to protest the Center's decision to swap currency notes to control black money.The central government has withdrawn existing 500 and 1000 rupee notes and asked everyone holding the same to get them exchanged with new notes from their nearest banks.The move is se...
Religious man denies breastmilk to newborn for 24 hrs A man from God’s own country has come under social media fire for preventing his wife from feeding their newborn child over religious reasons.The incident took place on Wednesday around 2 PM, at the EMS co-operative hospital in Mukkam in Kozhikode district, Kerala, where 24-year-old Hafsath refused to breastfeed her newborn baby, when the nurse asked to ...
Finally, Kerala CM takes a stand on Lawyers vs Media fight Almost three months after the tussle between various lawyers associations and journalists first hit the headlines, Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan today took a stand on the issue, urging lawyers to let the media do their job."The lawyers should realize that they do wrong in blocking journalists from accessing the court premises," Vijayan said in a...
Amit Shah wishes ‘Vaman Jayanti’ on Onam It is customary for politicians to wish people on festivities. Doing so is supposed to give the audience a feeling that the politician connects with them and shares in their joy.However, it is also possible for this to have unintended consequences in a different cultural context.BJP President Amit Shah wished his followers 'Vaman Jayanti' (Brahmin Bi...
BMW experience tour reaches Thrissur this weekend BMW announced the dates of its experience tour to be held in Thrissur district in Kerala on the 20th and 21st of this month.The venue will be Corporation ground in Paravattani added the company.Participants will be allowed to test drive and know more in detail about the BMW models, services and offerings, the company said.Various models from ...
Police crack Kerala’s Nirbhaya case, arrest Amiyur Islam Kerala Police have cracked the controversial case of the brutal rape and murder of Jisha, a law student in Perumbavoor near Kochi in Kerala.Amiyur Islam, a Bengali-speaking migrant labourer with an Assamese address, was arrested three days ago in Palghat.The body of the girl, Jisha, was found on April 28. Her injuries totalled 38, including some very...
KERALA ELECTION: Why BJP is in as much trouble as the Congress On the face of it, things went well for the Bharatiya Janata Party yesterday in Kerala.After decades of efforts at break into a two-party system, the saffron outfit finally managed to win its first seat in the state legislative assembly this time with party veteran O Rajagopal finding luck, and votes, in Nemom constituency near the capital Trivandrum. ...
Left likely to form next govt, leads Kerala Assembly Election Results, BJP ahead in 2 places The Left Democratic Front is indeed likely to form the next government in Kerala going by initial trends that give it a slight edge.According to official results, LDF is ahead in 88 out of 140 seats, followed by UDF or Congress in 50 seats and NDA in 1 seat. See the chart below:LEADSUDF 50LDF 88BJP 1(total) 139...
KERALA POLLS: BJP, Congress face common enemy in the Left Today's elections to the Kerala state assembly creates an unusual dilemma for supporters of the Bharatiya Janata Party in Kerala -- their long-term interest is in ensuring a Congress win to keep the Left out, but doing so will come at the expense of the BJP continuing to look like a promising new car that just never starts.ENEMY'S ENEMYThere are ...
Admins of Kerala Facebook group face death threats over anti-religious posts Screenshot source: naradanews.comThe administration panel of Kerala's biggest anti-superstition and rationalist Facebook groups has come under death threats for prompting believers to desert the Islamic faith.The blog, named Mujahir 2015, is written in Malayalam, the language spoken in Kerala."Those who insult the Prophet must be killed," the bl...
TERI – Ashok Chawla is new chairman, RK Pachauri to go on leave The Governing Council of TERI appointed former finance secretary Ashok Chawla as its new chairman and said RK Pachauri will be on leave."Dr. R.K. Pachauri, who had been at the Head of the Institute since 1982 will be on leave from TERI, TERI Governing Council, and TERI University till this is reviewed by the Governing Council given the subjudice natu...
Supreme Court sends notice to Center on Muslim divorce laws in India The Supreme Court today sent notice to the central government in a case based on a complaint by a Muslim woman that the divorce laws applied to her in India are not in conformity with the concept of gender equality promised by the Indian constitution.The court today sought the Union Government's reply on questions including whether the Muslim Personal La...
Centre to push for 50% reservation for women in Panchayat elections The government today said that it will push amendments for increasing to 50 per cent the reservation for women in Panchayats from 33 percent in the coming Budget session of Parliament.The move comes even as a bill to ensure women's representation in the Parliament continues to languish for lack of political support.Speaking at a National Workshop h...