POLL: A neutral alternative to Facebook’s Net Neutrality campaign

Facebook is claiming in an advertisement that 3.2 mln of its users have sent letters to the TRAI supporting its ‘free basics’ program in the context of the ongoing debate about net neutrality.

However, it did not reveal how many of its users refused to send the email, or at least how many were shown the option of sending the email, which would have given us an indirect way to gauge what percentage of Facebook’s India users support the program and what percentage don’t support it.

For example, if Facebook showed the notification to 50 mln users out of which 25 mln clicked on it and 3.2 mln actually sent the email without changing its content, it would mean that 3.2 out of 25 mln, or about 13% of Facebook users supported Free Basics.

That would also mean that about 87% of Facebook users chose not to click on the ‘send’ button for various reasons, including doubts about what exactly they were being asked to support.

The social network also did not clarify how it figured out that the 3.2 mln people who sent emails using its platform were actually ‘in support’ of its Free Basics program, as many changed the contents of the email to ‘I don’t support Free Basics’, according to testimonies on social media.

So, utill Facebook also reveals how many millions refused to send its email, or sent changed the contents of its email after changing its contents, the 3.2 mln number means very little.

THE DEBATE IN SHORT

The net neutrality debate comprises two parts — actual network neutrality and tariff neutrality.

Network Neutrality means that your telecom operator should treat all data — whether destined for Google, Facebook, Times of India or Hindustan Times — equally and not make some of them fast and some of them slow. Allowing telecom companies such as Airtel, Vodafone and Idea to speed up the traffic to websites that pay them money and slow down the data going to websites who don’t pay them money will give them the power to decide what website and app you should use.

Tariff Neutrality means all data should be charged the same. In other words, you should be charged the same for each MB of data whether you are buying your items from Paytm or Flipkart or Amazon. This where Facebook’s Free Basics also gets involved.

netActivists fear that if there is no tariff neutrality, then again telecom companies will create a ‘special’ Internet which only has websites that pay them, and jack up the tariff for the ‘normal’ Internet so much that most people won’t be able to afford it. The result, they fear, will be that over time 90% of the people will be on this ‘telecom company’ Internet which has only those websites that pay these telecom companies.

For example, this ‘small Internet’ may have Flipkart, but Amazon may be excluded because it doesn’t want to pay telcos. Most worryingly, they say, the rise of such ‘walled garden’ Internets will prevent the rise of new companies on the Internet as they won’t be able to pay the kind of money that Flipkart and Amazon pays to be on this new Internet.

As a result, starting new websites and launching new apps will become extremely costly and difficult as you have to negotiate with each telecom operator separately and keep paying each of them every month.

They see the first signs of such a system in Facebook’s ‘Free Basics’. To be on the platform, any website has to agree to Facebook’s terms and conditions. Companies who have refused to agree to Facebook’s terms and conditions have been kept out of ‘Free Basics’. Websites that have been kept out of Free Basics include Google.com, Naukri.com etc..

Telecom companies and Facebook argue that there is nothing wrong in making people who want the entire Internet pay more than those who want only the websites and apps that they have approved for use — like Free Basics. They say that people who sign up for ‘free Internet’ know exactly what they are getting — a limited set of websites and apps who pay the Internet provider or Facebook.

UPDATE: Facebook will be taking questions on Reddit India today on this topic.

What do you think: Do you think we should continue with both network neutrality and tariff neutrality? [socialpoll id=”2319076″]



TRAI wants FREE DATA for everyone, without ‘gatekeeping’ by telcos India's telecom regulator has suggested that every rural citizen should be given 100 MB or so per month on a free basis to help the spread of digital revolution in the country. It has also suggested allowing 'third party aggregators' like Facebook to offer free data, but only if they can keep telecom companies totally out of such efforts.Both suggestions...
Indian Railways releases list of 71 stations with free Wifi, to expand to 709 The Indian Railways has released a list of 71 railways stations in India with free Wifi provided by Google and Railwire, and said the facility will be extended to 709 stations in about three years from now.In addition, several suburban stations in Mumbai -- such as Kulra, Byculla, Belapur and Panvel -- also enjoy this facility at present.Under the fr...
NO DOWNLOADS: WhatsApp introduces ‘Direct Play’ for videos The upcoming version of WhatsApp messenger, which is currently in testing phase, has removed the 'download' button next to videos and has instead replaced it with a 'play' button.With this, users can directly play a video even without having to download the file first.SAVE BANDWIDTHThe main purpose of the feature is to help users to save their da...
Angry Bernie Sanders’ supporters say “We told you so!” on Trump election Even as many Bernie Sanders' supporters expressed disappointment, and even alarm, at the election of Donald J Trump as the next president of the USA, at least some of them felt vindicated by the results of the election.Sanders, a senator from Vermont, ran on a left-of-center, idealistic platform opposing the 'establishment' and nearly took the De...
Why Google Pixel smartphones make little sense at current prices Broadly, all brands can be divided into two types — mass brands and elite or premium brands.Mass brands are those used and preferred by ordinary people, while elite brands are confined to those who have very ‘refined’ tastes and for whom money is not usually a concern.Based on the above definition, Google is certainly a mass brand. It is the most use...
Reliance Jio increases no of channels on JioTV to 368 Reliance Jio has increased the number of TV channels on its JioTV app to 368, making it a potential competitor to DTH and cable TV platforms.JioTV, which started out as JioPlay, had only around 200 channels in the beginning. However, the platform has added about 50 channels every month over the last three months, taking the total to over 350 at present. ...
Reliance 4G offers 300 minutes of WhatsApp, FB calls for Rs 39 Untill now, to make calls using apps, you had to subscribe to a data pack.However, Reliance Communications has now introduced a new plan in which it will offer data for such app-to-app calls, but instead of billing you for the amount of data, it will bill you for the length of the calls.Typically, companies provide about 100 MB of data for about Rs 40. U...
Bharti Airtel calls TRAI’s bluff over net neutrality with intranet query As expected, telecom companies have rightly sought to exploit a loophole left open by the regulator and the government when they issued the famous 'net neutrality' guidelines earlier in the year.The TRAI and the government had, in February, banned any discriminatory charging for digital content flowing over their networks, and said that all bits should b...
Google Maps will now be more vocal about upcoming traffic jams If you're a regular user of Google Maps for navigation, you might want to update the app quickly before you head out.The latest version of Google News includes spoken warnings about traffic conditions, Google said. Till now, Google used to color code traffic conditions, with red indicating severe congestion and slow moving traffic."Now when you input...
Youtube Gaming now lets Indian gamers stream their play live Google has launched the YouTube Gaming mobile app on Android and iOS in India.YouTube Gaming is an app that seeks to keep gamers connected to the games, players, and culture with videos, live streams, and the community.Globally, video games are quite a spectator sport unlike in India where they are mostly a living room affair. In China for example, t...
Google Project Ara to soon release modular smartphone, not tablet; could surprise on price LG G5 with its 'cam module' attachedGoogle could release one of world's first truly modular mobile device -- one with user-replaceable parts -- as early as next month and it won't be a tablet, but a smartphone, according to person close to the company's Project Ara unit."People are saying it's a tablet because a benchmarking site said the screen s...
TRAI’s net neutrality rules could see zero-rated networks replace zero-rated websites in India The TRAI's new net neutrality rules are likely to see the launch of a number of zero-rated networks by players whose dreams of zero-rated websites have been dashed by the regulator.Under the new regulations, telecom companies have been banned from offering any website for free, but have been allowed to offer entire networks for free.What that means i...
TRAI’s new rules will mean the death of neutral Internet: Here’s why As you read this, India is celebrating the victory of 'net neutrality' over evil plans by Facebook and telecom companies to convert the Internet into a walled garden where they allow only those websites who pay monies to them.And you can't be blamed for it either.But guess what, the telcos are not crying either. That's because of a specific exemption...
‘Bold and Fair’, says Internet & Mobile Association on TRAI’s net neutrality r... The Internet and Mobile Association of India welcomed the Indian telecom regulator's move to ban differential pricing of data based on the type and source of content."This ruling vindicates the associations stand on the issue. The internet Start-up eco-system and the internet user community are delighted," it said.Taking a long-term view, the Tel...
Zee TV warns against plans by Airtel, Idea, Vodafone etc to dilute net neutrality Following Star TV and Sony, Zee TV has also come out strongly against any move to allow telecom operators to charge websites for content viewed by their consumers over the Internet.At present, any person is free to start a website, app or any other content service on the Internet, and telecom providers like Bharti Airtel, Idea Cellular, Reliance Jio and ...