Toxic Mercury in Lights: NGO accuses MNCs of double standards

cfMany international lighting companies are displaying double standards by challenging India’s new mercury recycling rules, said environmental NGO Toxics Link.

The NGO said these companies are resisting India’s new e-waste rules while conforming to them in other countries.

¨However, the same companies for long have been fulfilling their commitments under the waste of electrical and electronic equipment (WEEE) directive of the European Union(EU), and are responsible for the end of life management of mercury bearing lamps in all the member states of the EU.

It is ironical that they refuse to abide by similar rules in India and have challenged the government’s notification by moving a petition in the Delhi High Court.¨

The revised E-waste rules have brought compact fluorescent lamps (CFL) and other mercury containing lighting equipment under its ambit, by mandating that manufacturers have to take responsibility for the collection, transportation and disposal of fluorescent and other mercury-containing lamps under the EPR.

The rules have also set in place stringent provisions for violations. ¨By challenging the Rules, these companies have shown a blatant disregard for the laws of the land, besides making it amply clear that their responsibility to the environment is driven by a sense of geography rather than a sense of propriety,¨ said the NGO.

Even countries like Taiwan, Nigeria and many states in US and Canada have adopted the mandatory EPR for collection and recycling of mercury bearing lamps. Some countries like Australia, Hong Kong have adopted voluntary mechanism where the producers have played a key role for collection and recycling of these lamps.

“These companies are opposing the EPR principle in the new E-waste rules in India by challenging it in the court, which is in stark contrast to their actions in Europe. This exposes their double standards and reflects that these international companies have very little consideration for the adverse impacts of mercury on health of Indian citizens,” says Satish Sinha, Associate Director, Toxics Link.¨

The new E-waste Rules were notified in 2016 after sustained efforts of organisation’s like Toxics Link and others to include fluorescent and other mercury bearing lamps in the Rules.

The National Green Tribunal in its order dated July 7, 2015, had also instructed for the adoption of EPR for management of mercury- bearing lights.

¨This is a significant move towards meeting India’s global commitment to reduce adverse impacts of mercury emissions and protect human health and environment. Allowing these companies to flout the rules in India will be a step back.¨

Some of these companies have given information on their websites about them adhering to the WEEE directive.

“This clearly indicates that some of the petitioners, including Phillips, Osram, and General Electric have setup collection and recycling companies (Eco Lamp, EkoGaisma, Recolight) in various countries of Europe for environmentally sound management of mercury and mercury-bearing lamps,” said Piyush Mohapatra, Senior Programme Coordinator, Toxics Link.

“It is unfortunate that these international companies are opposing EPR in India. India is one of the biggest lighting markets of the world, perhaps larger than Europe. These companies have the experience of collecting and recycling mercury-bearing lights in an environmentally sound manner, which they have been doing in Europe for a long time. Instead of opposing the Rules, they should come forward and set an example by setting up systems in India. This will not only help protect the environment, but will also create green jobs in the country,” said Ravi Agarwal, Director, Toxics Link.

Toxics Link is an environmental research and advocacy organisation set up in 1996 by The Just Environment Charitable Trust.



Mumbai’s Viviana Mall installs India’s largest rooftop solar plant Viviana Mall in Mumbai has installed one of the largest single-site solar plants in India.The mall, located in Thane, has constructed a 900,000 volt-ampere rooftop solar power plant, which the company said was the biggest in India.900,000 volt-ampere refers to the peak capacity of the power plant. It implies that at full power (during noon on a sunny...
Delhi Pollution Control Board extends shutdown of NTPC Badarpur plant till January NTPC Ltd said the Delhi Pollution Control Committee has given directions to keep all its units in Badarpur Thermal Power Station closed till January 31, 2017.The reason for the committees direction has not been disclosed by NTPC. However, the reason is likely to be concerns around poor air quality in Delhi.The plant was first shut down earlier this y...
L&T partners with Microsoft to set up “Green Campuses” L&T Technology Services, the information technology company of the L&T group, said it has partnered with Microsoft Corporation to offer a solution to lower energy bills and cost of maintenance.L&T Technology Service's Integrated Building Energy Management Systems (iBEMS) framework will be available on Microsoft’s Azure cloud platform enab...
Star rating for Indian mines by next month, satellite monitoring to check illegal activity The government of India will introduce a star rating for mines by next month and start monitoring mining activity using satellite, said mining secretary Balvinder Kumar said at an ASSOCHAM event held in New Delhi today."If (mines)y don’t get 4 or 5 star rating they will get 2-3 years to comply. By end of November, we will finish first phase of star ratin...
Tired of waiting, Govt gives more teeth to Clean Ganga Authority The government has approved the setting up of National Mission for Clean Ganga in the place of the existing National Ganga River Basin Authority to fast track rejuvenation projects.The authority will have powers to issue directions and also to exercise the powers under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 to enable it to carry out efficiently its manda...
Wonderla Hyderabad waterpark installs 500 kW solar plant Wonderla amusement park had set up a solar plant with an installed capacity of 500kW at it´s newly opened unit in Hyderabad.The installed solar plant will generate 2000 units of power daily and it is expected cater to 25 percent of Wonderla's daily power requirement. The capacity can be enhanced to 1000kW.By this venture it becomes the first amusemen...
Ducon, Chinese co to market NOx catalyst for power plants in India Ducon Infratechnologies, a technology company providing solutions in the digital and infrastructure space, signed an agreement with Zhejiang Hailiang Ecological Materials of China to market and distribute DeNOx catalyst -- used to reduce nitrogen oxide emissions from thermal power plants.Ducon's DeNOx systems uses catalysis technology and control eng...
Rs 560 crore Ganga cleaning project launched at Kanpur Union Minister for Water Resources, River Development and Ganga Rejuvenation Sushri Uma Bharti launched various projects worth Rs 560 crore under Namami Gange programme at Ganga Barrage in Kanpur today, said ministry of water resource.This includes Rs 63 crore interception and diversion plan of Sisamau drain, Rs 397 crore networking schemes and river fro...
SC asks auto dealers to pay 1% environment cess on big diesel cars The Supreme Court has directed all manufacturers and dealers of Delhi & National Capital region selling diesel cars with engine capacity of 2000 cc and above, to pay 1% Environment Protection Charge.Supreme Court’s instructions came in the matter of M.C Mehta vs Union Vehicular Pollution Case: Diesel Emission) of India on Environment Protection C...
Burning waste could be leading to more lighting deaths — CSE A new study by Down To Earth magazine has unearthed clear links between air pollution and the incidence of deaths by lightning.According to an article in the magazine, published by the Center for Science and Environment or CSE, areas with high particulate pollution tend to experience more number of extreme weather events.Lightning deaths in the past...
BARC cuts cost of Chromium detection by 84% with new device BARC (Bhabha Atomic Research Centre) said they developed a portable kit to detect toxic chromium in drinking water and tap water, lakes, rivers as well as ground water at a cost of Rs 16 per sample.Existing kits for onsite detection of Hexavalent Chromium are currently imported and the cost of analysis is beyond Rs100 per sample, said BARC.Chromium i...
Delhi awareness drive saves Tata Power enough to light thousands of homes Tata Power said it had saved enough energy through an awareness program in New Delhi to light up thousands of homes in the city.The company said it saved around 9.5 lakh units of power.It did this by creating energy conservation clubs in 25 schools across the city.Tata Power said its Club Enerji movement in New Delhi currently has 4,266 Energy ...
CNG-fueled bikes? Why not, says the government After autorickshaws, cars and buses, the government is now targeting the two-wheelers for CNG conversion.A pilot CNG-program under GAIL and Indraprastha Gas will test the suitability of CNG as a fuel for two-wheelers.Typically, natural gas is not considered an ideal fuel for smaller vehicles. However, given its low pollution footprint, the fuel was a...
IGL opens 72 new CNG outlets in 4 months, to open 18 this month Indraprastha Gas Limited said it opened 72 outlets of compressed natural gas in the national capital region in the last four months and another 18 will be opened this month.These have been opened at the fuel outlets of Indian Oil, BPCL and HPCL."While 51 out of these 72 CNG fuelling facilities are located in NCT of Delhi, 21 are located in NCR towns...
Bajaj Auto increases Qute production, says it beats popular cars in safety ranking Responding to widespread news that its low-priced quadricycle Qute has got a European safety ranking of just 1 out of 5 in crash tests, Bajaj Auto today said the rank is still better than that of many popular cars."In a recent Euro NCAP report, the Bajaj Qute was accorded a 1 star rating, superior to the 0 star rating of popular cars including the VW...